While we can turn on the news each day to hear the latest statistics on the number of COVID-19 related infections and deaths that have occurred, there is no statistic on the number of souls it has swept away. When I speak of souls, I am not speaking of it in the religious context of what may leave your body upon your death. Rather, I am speaking of the spirit inside of each of us, that makes us want to get up in the morning and look forward to the day. I am talking about the spirit that makes life worth living. I am speaking about the joy one gets when holding a loved one’s hand. And specifically, I am talking about the souls of the 1.5 million residents of nursing homes in America and their families.
While I could also write about the millions of small business owners, their families and the families of their employees that have also been crushed by the virus, I have chosen to write about nursing homes due to my personal experiences.
My Mom, Joan, has been in a nursing home in Charlotte County, Florida, since June of 2019. She is bedridden and cannot feed herself, but her mind was still operating at about 80% before COVID-19 hit. We had great conversations about our lives, watched old movies and NFL football. I would see her three or four times a week.
I visited her on Saturday, March 7, 2020, for lunch. As was typical, I brought one of her favorite foods, usually, Chinese food, pizza or Chick-Fil-A. Never could I have imagined that day that I would not be able to sit in her room with her and have lunch with her for over six months. On March 10, 2020, the facility implemented a no visitation policy.
An additional challenge I have in communicating with my Mom is that she is almost deaf, has lost vision in one eye due to glaucoma and her other eye has about 50% of her vision. At first, I would drop off some of her favorite snacks with notes in large print so I could maintain contact. After a few weeks, the nursing home set up FaceTime calls so I could at least see her and talk to her a little. Even with headphones and the volume turned all the way up, she could only hear about 50% of what I said.
When I thought things couldn’t get worse for my Mom, they did. First, they stopped all outside packages from coming into the place. Therefore, my communication was now limited to the FaceTime calls. Second, I received a call that she tested positive for COVID-19 but, was asymptomatic at the time (fortunately she never showed any symptoms); Third, as my mother is ornery sometimes, there was one CNA that had a great relationship with her who my mother actually grew to love, Hazel. I called Hazel to get her take on how my mother was doing only to have her answer her cell phone in the hospital to tell my she had it! Now my mother lost me and the one real friend she had at her place.
At first, I think like most of us, I thought this situation would only last a month, maybe two at most. So I kept telling my Mom to hang on and I would be able to be back with her soon.
Adding another twist to this virus experience, about three weeks into this lockdown, I get word that my mom’s first cousin, my Aunt Patricia, who was in her early 60’s, was hospitalized with the virus. Unfortunately, she was misdiagnosed at first and, instead of the virus, she had an aggressive form of cancer and was dead in three days. There was no such thing as a normal funeral, and wake, and grieving, so my uncle and cousins along with my Aunt’s brother, had to grieve without the support of family to hold them and comfort them. Again, all families who have lost loved ones during this time, whether from COVID-19 or other illnesses, have lost the opportunity to grieve and get support from friends and family as we normally would pre-virus. More millions of souls that have lost part of themselves due to this pandemic.
By the time June rolls around, my Mom is declining and not understanding why I can’t visit her. She would argue with me and the CNA’s, “All these other people come in and out each day, why can’t you?” While I tried to explain to her that government restrictions prohibited it, for someone in her condition, it was incomprehensible. I tried to reason with her and explain to her that that, at the time, the NCAA Men’s basketball tournament was cancelled (which she loved), the NBA postponed its season, as well as Major League Baseball. When games did come back, I tried to explain to her that they were going on without fans in the stands to somehow justify why I couldn’t see her. My explanations were met by silence.
As July came and went, my Mom was less and less communicative on our FaceTime calls. She also started to became angrier with her CNA’s and nurses. She began eating less and less and refused to take her medication. In the beginning of August, it was recommended that hospice be brought in.
To backtrack a little, in June, when it became apparent that this virus was not under control and that there was no end in sight, I began asking when they were going to set up some sort of in person visitation. As was advised that there would have to be a 60-day period of no COVID cases among patients and staff before they could implement an in person visitation policy. While my Mom is on the first floor and I could go to her window to see her, she was too far away to communicate with her and, when I was there, it was difficult for her to recognize me. At times, she would deny it was me and say if it was really me I would come in and help her. She was now constantly displaying understandable anger and frustration.
Back to August, as far as an in person visit possibility, I had lost all hope of that as, on average, twice a week I was receiving a CDC required call from the facility of a new COVID-19 case either among patients or staff. When you add 60 days to each case and my Mom’s deteriorating condition, it seemed time was running out.
As I mentioned, hospice had been brought in and my Mom was assigned a wonderful hospice nurse. I asked how and when I could get to see my Mom. She told me that the facility was allowing visitors when the patient was “near the end.” That is not what I wanted to hear because I wanted the opportunity to still be able to communicate with my Mom and that just seemed too late. However, the reality was, while my mom was not quite at the end, her mind had pretty left her by mid-August, at least as far as being the Mom I knew for 86 and a half years.
On Tuesday, August 18, 2020, I received a call from the hospice nurse. She said if I agreed that my Mom was in decline, she would arrange for a visit. Two days later, on Thursday morning August 20, 2020 at 9:28 a.m., two minutes before a Zoom Hearing on a foreclosure Case Management Conference, my cell phone rings and I recognize the number. I immediately pick up the phone and its someone from my mom’s facility asking if I would like to come in that day to see my Mom in person. I immediately run from my conference room to my desk to check my calendar and tell her I could do it at three o’clock. I hung up and ran back to the conference room for my court appearance. Afterwards, I realized I had a 3:30 client meeting and had to have my assistant re-schedule.
As the time to leave to go visit my Mom grew closer, I grew more and more nervous. The last few FaceTime calls with my Mom had not been great as she didn’t want to speak with me. While I understand her anger and frustration, it’s not easy to experience her reaction after having a wonderful mother/son relationship our entire lives but for these last six months of COVID-19.
Arriving at the facility was surreal. I had not been allowed in the building for six months. As I arrived wearing my mask, I am met by a social worker who takes me through a set of double doors. In the past, after walking through these doors, I would make a right down a long hallway and then make a left when I got to the nurses’ station, past a dozen or so patients gathered there talking and listening to music. I’d then walk all the way down the next wing to my Mom’s room, the last one on the right. However, this time, my first stop was to get dressed in protective garb. First, a navy blue cloth robe that tied in the back. Then a N95 mask covered by the lighter weight mask I wore into the facility. Next I had to wrestle with trying to figure out how to put on a clear glass shield around my head and over my face. Finally, I put on rubber gloves. While I felt like I was being prepared to perform a surgery, it gave me a whole new understanding and respect for the millions of healthcare workers who have to wear this equipment every day for 8 to 12 hour shifts.
Once dressed, instead of going to the right as I normally would to go to my Mom’s room, we walked straight ahead, through a side door, out into a courtyard, then back into the building and to the nurses station I had walked by hundreds of times. However, this time, there was no music and no one was sitting around. In fact, all the chairs and couches had been removed. The social worker left me there alone to walk the last hallway by myself. As I walked down the long corridor, I saw a few residents sitting in their doorways as well as some CNA’s, but I realized they could not see me smiling at them or recognize who I was, so I just awkwardly waived at them.
When I walked into my mother’s room, it was startling sterile. While the pictures we had brought were still on the wall, the table we usually put flowers or decorated for the holidays was pushed into the corner. Her bed which usually had some colorful blanket or afghan on it, just had white hospital sheets. Her bedside table usually covered with snacks, just had a white Styrofoam cup of ice water.
I sat down next to her as I normally would and shouted a number of times “Hi Mom! It’s me, Mark!” I’m not sure if she could recognize me, but she did open her eyes a couple of times so she knew someone was there. At some point, I do believe she knew it was me, but her face had more of an angered look than what I had hoped for. Through sterile rubber gloves, I was able to touch her hand, her arm and her face. I don’t know how aware she was of my presence. I sat there looking at my Mom, never imagining that this would be how the end would be, not understanding why any merciful higher being would do this to a human being. Frankly, I am very angry that this virus took away the last months I would have had with my Mom. It simply has beat her down with loneliness, isolation, frustration and anger. While I am grateful that I did finally get to be with her in the physical sense, it was too late to experience her inner soul, her laugh, and the joy she once felt for life, that part of my Mom was already gone.
My Mom and I are not alone in this journey. There are approximately 1.5 million residents of nursing homes in our country and the patients and their families add up to the millions. All of us are suffering through these times. While are loved ones may not be infected with the virus and dying, their souls are withering away. There is a devastating toll being taken on all of us in this situation, but there are no “official counts” on the evening news to measure the extent of the mental and spiritual damage. To say that the country is coming back because the stock market is all the way back is meaningless to those of us with loved ones in nursing homes.
As I walked out of my Mom’s room, I looked across the hall and saw that her neighbor, Max, whom I had gotten to know, had his name removed from the name plate. I asked and found out that he had succumbed to the virus as many on her wing had in the last six months. While waiting for the social worker to come back to escort me out, in speaking to one of the nurses, she said she never wanted to live through another April and May for the rest of her life.
If you have a similar story of loss, heartbreak or soul crushing experiences, whether if be from loss of a loved one, or a family business, I encourage you to share it so that Americans understand the true extent of the damage this virus has done to our country. I know this is only one area of irreparable harm that is occurred and there are millions of other different stories for small businesses, restaurants and farms. Again, please share your stories so the real devastation of COVID-19 is known to the world.
My Mom had a knack she received from her dad, to make up nicknames for people. One of mine growing up was “Marcus Aurelius.” While I had no idea who he was while growing up as a kid, as an adult, I’ve become a student of his Stoic philosophy and feel it is only appropriate to leave you with this quote: “Adapt yourself to the things among which your lot has been cast and love sincerely the fellow creatures with whom destiny has ordained that you shall live.”
-By Mark Martella, Esq.
